During periods of stagflation, where inflation is high, economic growth is stagnant, and unemployment rates are elevated, making sound investment decisions becomes especially critical. Stagflation presents a challenging environment for investors as traditional strategies may not be as effective in such conditions. Inflation erodes the real value of investments, while stagnant economic growth limits the potential for strong returns.
One approach for navigating investments during stagflation is to diversify your portfolio across various asset classes such as stocks, bonds, real estate, and commodities. Diversification can help reduce risk and protect against potential losses in one particular asset class.
What is Stagflation?
Stagflation is a challenging economic condition characterized by high inflation, low growth, and high unemployment. It can result from a negative supply shock that reduces an economy's productive capacity and increases costs, or from a mismatch between aggregate demand and supply from behavioral or structural factors.
Stagflation poses several challenges for policymakers, businesses, and consumers. It can lead to lower living standards and higher poverty rates for consumers, lower profits and higher uncertainty for businesses, lower tax revenues and higher deficits for governments, and higher interest rates and lower bond prices for investors.
Resolving stagflation is problematic because it requires a delicate balance between monetary and fiscal policies, both of which can have unintended consequences. Monetary policy can control inflation by raising interest rates and reducing the money supply, which may worsen the economic slowdown and increase unemployment. Fiscal policy can stimulate growth by increasing government spending and reducing taxes, but it can also fuel inflation and increase public debt.
Importance of Considering Stagflation Risk When Investing
Stagflation can impact your investments in varying ways across different asset classes, causing increased volatility and uncertainty in financial markets. When investing, consider stagflation risk to adjust asset allocation and diversification strategies according to your risk tolerance and return objectives.
Identifying opportunities and threats for different sectors and industries, monitoring indicators and signals, and hedging against adverse effects of stagflation using various instruments and strategies can all help mitigate this risk.
Top Stagflation Investments
Stagflation doesn't have to spell disaster for your financial goals. To stay ahead, consider the following investment options.
Gold and Precious Metals
Gold is a reliable asset that can safeguard against inflation and currency devaluation while maintaining its value over time. It's also rare and durable, making it resilient to supply and demand fluctuations. In past stagflation periods, gold has performed well. Between January 1971 and March 2024, gold delivered an annualized average return of 7.98%, compared to the 8% returned by commodities in the same period.
To get the best out of your gold investment:
- Diversify your portfolio with a mix of physical gold, gold exchange-traded funds (ETFs), gold mining stocks, and gold futures and options. You can buy physical gold or invest through a Gold IRA.
- Allocate a percentage of your portfolio to gold and precious metals based on your risk tolerance, investment objectives, and time horizon – typically 5% to 10%.
- Stay informed on market trends and economic indicators that impact gold and precious metals, including inflation rates, interest rates, central bank policies, geopolitical events, and consumer sentiment.
- Have a clear investment strategy and discipline to avoid emotional trading and time the market.
- Remember to buy low and sell high but keep in mind the bigger picture of your investment goals.
- Use technical analysis tools like moving averages, trend lines, and support and resistance levels to spot entry and exit points.
Real Estate
Real estate is a valuable asset class that can guard against inflation and economic slowdown. It can appreciate over time and earn rental income for owners. Real estate also benefits from low interest rates and high demand for housing during stagflation.
You can purchase physical properties such as residential or commercial buildings or invest in real estate investment trusts (REITs) or ETFs that invest in REITs.
In stagflation, rental properties can offer steady cash flow from rent, value appreciation, and tax advantages. REITs can expose you to a wide range of real estate sectors and markets. You also earn a stable income from the dividend payout.
Before venturing into real estate, consider your goals and risk tolerance, the type and location of real estate, and the quality and performance of the real estate.
Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS)
TIPS are government-issued bonds that protect against inflation by adjusting their principal value according to changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). They pay a fixed interest rate every six months, based on the adjusted principal value, making them a potentially good investment during stagflation as they guarantee a return above inflation.
Investing in TIPS offers a guaranteed real rate of return and hedges against inflation risk. It has very low default risk due to being backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. TIPS are eligible for the Separately Traded Interest and Principal of Securities (STRIPS) program, allowing investors to separate principal and interest components and trade them as zero-coupon securities.
However, TIPS can present interest rate, liquidity, tax, and inflation measurement risks. These risks affect TIPS investors' bid-ask spread, transaction costs, and tax liability. Also, TIPS are based on the CPI, which may not reflect actual inflation experienced by individual investors.
To incorporate TIPS into an investment portfolio during stagflation:
- Start by allocating a portion of your fixed-income portfolio to TIPS, depending on your risk tolerance, time horizon, and inflation expectations.
- Assess the relative attractiveness of TIPS by comparing the yield difference between TIPS and nominal Treasury bonds of the same maturity, also known as the breakeven inflation rate.
- Choose the maturity of TIPS that matches your investment objectives and cash flow needs. You can buy TIPS directly from the Treasury or invest in them through mutual funds or ETFs specializing in TIPS or inflation-linked securities but be aware of fees, expenses, and tax implications.
- Weigh the risks and benefits of TIPS before making investment decisions.
Defensive Stocks
Defensive stocks provide essential goods or services unaffected by economic cycles. They offer stable earnings, high dividends, and low volatility, making them a potentially good investment during stagflation. These stocks can also benefit from their pricing power, loyal customers, and market share.
Utilities, consumer staples, and healthcare can be some of the best-performing sectors during these periods because of their low sensitivity to economic fluctuations, high dividend payouts, and strong demand for products or services.
To invest in defensive stocks during stagflation, search the stock market for companies with consistent earnings and dividend growth, high dividend yield, low payout ratio, low beta, high Sharpe ratio, high market share, and strong competitive advantage.
Stocks in this regard include Procter & Gamble (P.G.), Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), and NextEra Energy (NEE), which have a loyal customer base, diversified portfolio of brands, leading position in the healthcare industry and competitive edge in the clean energy sector, respectively.
Commodities
Commodities are raw materials or agricultural products traded on the global market and can be classified into four categories: energy, metals, agricultural, and livestock. During stagflation, investing in commodities can be lucrative as they can benefit from rising inflation, supply constraints, and demand shifts. Energy commodities, including oil and natural gas; precious metals like gold and silver; and agricultural commodities, such as corn, wheat, soybeans, and sugar, tend to perform exceptionally well,
Investors can invest in commodities by investing in companies with exposure to commodities or through futures contracts or ETFs.
However, commodities come with risks like price volatility, liquidity issues, leverage effects, and regulatory changes. To reduce exposure to these risks, investors should diversify their portfolios across different types of commodities and asset classes and conduct thorough research before making any investment decisions.
Stagflation Investment Strategies
While stagflation presents a formidable economic challenge, it doesn't have to spell disaster for your investments. By understanding the dynamics of this rare economic phenomenon and considering the right investment strategies, you can navigate these troubled waters successfully.
From the resilience of growth stocks to the enduring allure of gold, real estate, TIPS, defensive stocks, and commodities, the best investments in stagflation can not only protect your wealth but potentially thrive in a stagflationary environment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What assets do best in stagflation?
Are TIPS good during stagflation?
Yes, Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) can be a good investment during stagflation. They provide protection against inflation by adjusting their principal value with changes in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). This helps preserve purchasing power when inflation is high, a key characteristic of stagflation. However, TIPS may underperform if interest rates rise significantly due to slow economic growth, as higher real yields can reduce their relative attractiveness.
Do stocks go up during stagflation?
About Anna Yen
Anna Yen, CFA is an alternative investment writer with over two decades of professional finance and writing experience in roles within JPMorgan and UBS derivatives, asset management, crypto, and Family Money Map. She specializes in writing about alternative investment topics ranging from derivatives to real estate and cryptocurrencies. Her work has been published on sites like Quicken, the crypto exchange Bybit, and Credit.com.