Best Hurricane Insurance

If you live on the East Coast or the Gulf Coast, hurricanes are a risk to your home. Most homeowners insurance policies provide coverage for some hurricane risks, but not all hurricane-related risks. Here’s how hurricane insurance works and how to choose the best coverage.

Quick Look: Best Hurricane Insurance

• Best Overall: Amica
• Best for High-Value Home in Coastal Areas: PURE Insurance
• Best for Existing State Farm Customers: State Farm

3 Best Hurricane Insurance Companies

For most households, the best hurricane insurance coverage is part of the home coverage provided with the best homeowners insurance policies. However, some home insurance providers may not write policies in all states or in areas nearest to the coast of your state. Homeowners closest to the coast or those with high-value homes should consider speaking to an independent agent who can find the coverage you need for your home.

1. Best Overall: Amica

For those further up the East Coast, Amica is a solid choice for homeowners and offers a number of benefits that may cost more with other insurers. In some areas, you may even be able to add earthquake or flood coverage for your home.

Amica’s Platinum Choice policy offers up to 30% more coverage for your home than a standard policy. You’ll also find included extras, like replacement cost coverage for your belongings without a deduction for depreciation, sewer backup coverage and even extended coverage for business property at your home, such as a laptop.

Expect exceptional claim service from Amica, the top-rated company in J.D. Power’s 2018 home insurance customer satisfaction survey. With over 100 years of experience protecting families and an A+ financial rating from A.M. Best, Amica has the staying power you’ll want in a home insurance company.

Read Benzinga's full Amica Insurance Review

Get a custom quote with Kin Insurance and see why this up-to-the-minute insurance company satisfies Florida homeowners all across the Sunshine State.

2. Best for High-Value Home in Coastal Areas: PURE Insurance

PURE is a newer insurer with a focus on high-value homes often found in coastal areas.

High-value homes and high-net-worth households have special coverage considerations and PURE has proven its ability to cover the needs of customers in many coastal states like Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, New York, New Jersey, South Carolina, Texas and Maryland.

Expect white-glove claims service and options that aren’t available from many other insurers, like cash settlement (instead of rebuilding) and guaranteed replacement cost coverage. Flood insurance can be added to your policy bundle as well.

3. Best for Existing State Farm Customers: State Farm

Financial strength and a wide network of agents are important and State Farm has you covered.

As with other insurers, home insurance may not be available in all areas, but State Farm covers most inland coastal areas and coverage may also be available through affiliated companies so you can take advantage of multi-policy discounts.

Expect prompt claims clearance and knowledgeable agents. Rates can vary by location, insured value and individual rating factors, but State Farm often compares favorably compared to other insurers’ home insurance rates. Flood insurance coverage can be added as a separate policy through agents enrolled in the NFIP-Direct program.

Read Benzinga's full State Farm Insurance Review

Top 10 Costliest Hurricanes U.S. History

What Hurricane Insurance Covers

To be clear, hurricane coverage doesn’t usually require a separate type of insurance. Coverage for some types of hurricane-related damage is covered by a standard home insurance policy or by a rider but some types of damage aren’t covered. Your deductible can also play a big role in how well your policy protects your home.

In some of the highest-risk areas, some insurers may not offer wind coverage as part of your home insurance policy at all. You may have to seek private market wind coverage — if you can find it — or turn to state-sponsored solutions, like the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA) or Citizens Property Insurance Corporation in Florida. Alabama, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina and South Carolina also offer high-risk wind and hail coverage through a state-mandated “wind pool.”

There’s no legal requirement to purchase home insurance or wind coverage, but lenders require home insurance if you have a home loan and specialized wind coverage may also be required by lenders in some areas.

Hurricanes can pose several major risks to your home:

• Wind
• Hail
• Rain
• Sewer backup
• Flooding
• Storm surge

Of these risks, only some are covered by a standard home insurance policy. If you do have coverage for damage due to a hurricane, the claim can trigger a separate deductible on your policy. The deductible is the part of the claim that you pay — and with hurricane claims, the deductible can be sizeable.

• Wind: A standard home insurance policy covers damage due to wind in most areas but if you live in an area at risk for hurricane damage, it’s likely that you’ll have a special deductible.
• Hail: Wind and hail damage are often grouped together in policy details and may have the same deductible.
• Rain: Coverage for damage from rain is split between rainwater that enters the home through the roof, upper walls or windows and rainwater that seeps in through the basement or comes in under the doors. The latter scenarios are considered flooding and aren’t covered by a home insurance policy.
• Sewer backup: This coverage is usually offered as a rider, which is an add-on to your policy. Without the rider, there may not be any coverage.

A standard home insurance policy doesn’t provide protection against flood damage. Generally speaking, if the water touched the ground before entering your home, it’s a flood and it isn’t covered by home insurance. This includes storm surges. For flood coverage, you’ll need a separate flood insurance policy through the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) or a private market flood insurance provider.

Hurricane Insurance vs. Homeowners Insurance

Unless you live near the shoreline in a state with wind pool coverage, specialized wind insurance policies are a rarity. However, it’s common to find some differences in coverage for hurricane-related damage on a standard home insurance policy when compared to other types of damage.

Insurance is governed at the state level, so while there are some commonalities for coverage, some states may handle some aspects of coverage differently than other states.

Percentage-Based Deductibles

Your home insurance policy may have more than one type of deductible. In some states, you may also have a wind and hail deductible but there may also be a named storm or hurricane deductible. For covered claims not related to wind, hail or named storms, the standard deductible applies. For covered claims due to named storms, including hurricanes, the named storm deductible applies, which is often higher than the standard deductible.

It’s common for insurers to use a percentage-based deductible for named storm coverage. This deductible can range from 1% to 10% of the insured value of the home. A home insured for $300,000 with a 5% named storm or hurricane deductible would be subject to a $15,000 deductible for covered claims resulting from the storm. Choosing a higher deductible often lowers premiums but also increases your out-of-pocket costs in a claim.

Some states, like Texas, don’t allow a separate hurricane deductible and the wind/hail deductible applies regardless of if a named storm caused the damage.

It’s important to do the math when you choose a percentage-based deductible. The policy may have a minimum deductible with an option to use a higher deductible to save money on premiums. The risk is that you may not have enough money to repair or rebuild your home if you can’t cover the deductible amount.

Dollar-Limit Based Deductibles

In some cases, hurricane deductibles are a simple dollar figure. For example, you may have a $2,500 hurricane deductible. In the event of a covered claim for $10,000, the insurer will pay out $7,500, although it’s possible the insurer will require that the repairs be done before they pay the claim in full.

Flood Insurance

Hurricanes cause floods, overflowed rivers and streams, breached levees or dams and storm surges. Home insurance won’t cover any of these risks. If flooding is a concern, you may need a flood insurance policy. In most cases, you can get coverage through an agent that sells Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the national flood insurance program coverage. In some areas, you can also purchase private market coverage, which often also offers higher coverage limits than a FEMA policy.

The Cost of Hurricane Insurance

For policies that include hurricane coverage, the risk of hurricane damage can play a big role in premium amounts. For example, the average cost of home insurance for an inexpensive home is nearly $4,000 per year in Florida. This is nearly triple the average cost nationwide for similar homes, and in many areas, the cost of coverage is under $1,000 per year. The big difference in cost is due to risk.

When a home in Michigan is damaged due to a burst pipe, it’s a single-home event and it’s rare that the damage results in a total loss. By comparison, a home on the Gulf Coast damaged by a hurricane isn’t a single-home event. Homeowners in several states may be affected by the storm and insurers use wind or named storm deductibles to help manage costs when there’s widespread damage.

The cost of coverage for state wind pools can vary because each solution is state-specific. An independent agent can help you secure wind coverage in these areas and may also be able to provide excess wind coverage, which can extend your coverage limit if the base policy limits are exceeded.

Ideally, you should have enough coverage to protect yourself against a total loss. There are cases where, after a storm, there is no home to come back to. In other cases, the extent of the damage requires a total rebuild. Your insurer can help you calculate an amount to use for dwelling coverage to repair or rebuild your home. Typically, the personal property coverage, which covers your belongings, is set at a percentage of the home’s insured value. An amount equal to 50% of the home’s insured value is common.

In all cases, you’ll want to be insured for at least 80% of the cost of rebuilding. Homes insured for lesser amounts can be subject to coinsurance, which means you pay a percentage of the claim as well as the deductible. For example, a home with a $50,000 claim that’s insured for 50% of the cost of rebuilding will only get $25,000 for the covered claim, less the deductible.

Choose the Best Hurricane Coverage

If your home overlooks the ocean or the Gulf, chances are good that you’ll need a regional or specialty insurer. Seek the guidance of a local agent who has experience providing coverage for high-risk areas. For areas further inland but still within reach of the beach, you’ll find you have a wider choice of insurers and hurricane coverage is likely to be included with your home insurance policy.

Keep a close eye on deductibles. In many cases, it’s worth the higher premium to have a lower deductible when it’s time to repair your home after a storm.

Want to learn more about home insurance? Check out Benzinga's guide to the best home insurance companies, the best moving insurance, the best earthquake insurance and the best flood insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions