Benzinga's Online Brokerage Review Methodology
We aim to provide comprehensive and unbiased reviews on Benzinga to help users understand and learn about brokerage and investing platforms. Below you'll find a detailed methodology for how we rank brokers in our content.
Our Methodology Scores
Factors | Weight |
Usability | 10% |
Services Offered | 15% |
Customer Service | 15% |
Education | 10% |
Research, News and Data | 25% |
Mobile App | 10% |
Account Min | 10% |
Fees | 5% |
Review Process
For brokerage reviews, Benzinga created a weighted scale based on the following criteria: usability, services offered, customer service, education, research, mobile app, account minimums and fees. Reviewers meticulously researched each category and rate based on the following metrics.
Usability Criteria
Our usability score accounts for 10% of the overall rating. We looked at factors such as onboarding time, an easily navigable site and the ability to make a trade with minimal effort and previous experience.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | New customers onboarded less than 10 minutes Reviewer can easily navigate the site and find everything necessary to make a trade with no difficulty Teaches users how to use the platform Screen reader support enabled |
4 | New customers onboarded less than 10 minutes Reviewer can navigate the site and find everything necessary to make a trade with little to no difficulty |
3 | New customers onboarded greater than 10 minutes Reviewer can navigate the site and find everything necessary to make a trade with little to some difficulty |
2 | New customers onboarded greater than 20 minutes Reviewer can navigate the site and find everything necessary to make a trade with difficulty |
1 | New customers onboarded greater than 20 minutes Reviewer can navigate the site and find everything necessary to make a trade with difficulty |
Services Offered Criteria
For this section, we looked at the number of asset classes that are available to traders and investors. It accounts for 15% of the overall rating. An example of a 5 star platform in this section has 7 asset classes and international securities.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | Offers stocks, ETFs, bonds, options, futures, forex Can trade international securities Offers 5+ account types |
4 | Offers (5/7) stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, bonds, options, futures, forex No access to foreign markets Offers 3-4 account types |
3 | Offers (4/7) stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, bonds, options, futures, forex No access to foreign markets Offers 2 account types |
2 | Only stocks, options Offers 1 account type |
1 | N/A |
Customer Service Criteria
This section accounts for 15% of the overall rating and we looked at the options available to contact customer service, if there were any special services for disabled users and how quickly a customer could contact customer service.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | Offers text chat, call, email options Special services for disabled Can chat with a live person in less than 2 minutes |
4 | Offers text chat, call, email options Special services for disabled Can chat with a live person in less than 5 minutes |
3 | Offers (2/3) text chat, call, email options Special services for disabled Can chat with a live person in less than 10 minutes |
2 | Offers (1/3) text chat, call, email options No special services for disabled Can chat with a live person in less than 15 minutes |
1 | Offers (1/3) text chat, call, email options No special services for disabled Can chat with a live person in less than 20 minutes |
Education Criteria
The education section accounts for 10% of the overall rating. An example of an online broker that has 5 stars has a full repository of educational materials such as blogs and tutorials, is well organized, connected to both mobile and desktop and offers retirement guidance.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | Full repository of educational material Well organized educational content Connected to mobile and desktop app Offers retirement guidance |
4 | Full repository of educational material Decently organized Either on mobile or desktop Offers retirement guidance |
3 | Has educational materials Decently organized Either on mobile or desktop Some retirement guidance |
2 | Few educational materials Not well organized Either on mobile or desktop Little retirement guidance |
1 | N/A |
Research, News and Data Criteria
For a platform to earn 5 stars in the research category they require customization capability for assets, a fixed income screener, market commentary, options research and access to analyst research. Most importantly considered in the rankings is access to news within the platform that is provided either internally or externally from trustworthy publishers. This accounts for 25% of the overall rating.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | Has customizable stock, ETF, mutual fund and fixed income screener Provides market commentary in the form of shows, webinars, podcasts, etc. Provides options research Access to analyst research |
4 | Has customizable stock, ETF, mutual fund and fixed income screener Provides market commentary Access to analyst research |
3 | Has stock research platform Provides market commentary Access to analyst research |
2 | Has minimal stock research platform No market commentary Little access to analyst research |
1 | No stock research No market commentary No access to analyst research |
Mobile App Criteria
For a platform to earn 5 stars in the mobile app category they require the same experience on desktop, ability to integrate between mobile and desktop, available on iOS and Android and is deemed easy to use. This accounts for 10% of the overall rating.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | The mobile app offers the same experience as desktop Integration between mobile and desktop Available iOS and Android Easy to use |
4 | Mobile App offers a similar experience as desktop Integration between mobile and desktop Available iOS and Android Easy to use |
3 | Mobile App offers a similar experience as desktop Integration between mobile and desktop Available iOS and Android Easy to a little difficult to use |
2 | Mobile App does not offers a similar experience as desktop Integration between mobile and desktop Available iOS or Android Little difficult to use |
1 | No mobile app |
Account Mininmum Criteria
For a platform to earn 5 stars in the account minimum category they require a $0 account minimum. This accounts for 10% of the overall rating.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | $0 to $100 account minimum |
4 | $101 to $250 account minimum |
3 | $251 to $500 account minimum |
2 | $501 to $2,000 account minimum |
1 | $2,001 + account minimum |
Fees Criteria
For a platform to earn 5 stars in the fees category they require free stock trading and $2 or less for options trades. This accounts for 5% of the overall rating.
Star Rating | Attributes |
5 | Stocks: Free $2 or less for options |
4 | Stocks: Free $2 to $5 for options |
3 | Stocks: up to $5 >$5 for options |
2 | Stocks: > $10 >$5 for options |
1 | Stocks: > $20 >$5 for options |
Specialties Ratings
For online brokers that focus specifically on one asset class, we created a separate methodology to apply to our rankings.
Asset | 5 stars | 4 Stars | 3 Stars | 2 Stars | 1 Star |
Forex | Offers Forex trading > 80 Forex pairs $0 account minimum < 0.8 PIPs per trade | Offers Forex trading > 80 Forex pairs $0 to $250 account minimum < 1 PIPs per trade | Offers Forex trading > 60 & < 80 Forex pairs $0 to $250 account minimum < 1.5 PIPs per trade | Offers Forex trading < 60 Forex pairs > $ 250 account minimum > 1.5 PIPs per trade | No forex trading |
Options | Offers options trading $0 account minimum < $0.65 per options contract | Offers options trading $0 account minimum > $0.65 per options contract | Offers options trading $0 to $250 account minimum > $0.65 per options contract | Offers options trading > $250 account minimum > $0.65 per options contract | No options trading |
ETFs | Free ETF trading Has ETF screener Has ETF educational material | Free ETF trading Has ETF screener Minimal ETF educational material | Only certain ETFs are free to trade Has ETF screener Minimal ETF educational material | Only certain ETFs are free to trade No ETF screener Minimal ETF educational material | No ETFs free to trade No ETF screener No ETF educational material |
Mutual Funds | Offers no-fee mutual funds No-load mutual funds < $20 fees Has mutual fund screener Offers > 2,000 mutual fund options | Offers no-fee mutual funds No-load mutual funds > $20 fees & < $40 Has mutual fund screener Offers > 2,000 mutual fund options | Offers no-fee mutual funds No-load mutual funds > $40 Has mutual fund screener Offers < 2,000 mutual fund options | All mutual funds have costs No-load mutual funds > $40 Has mutual fund screener Offers < 2,000 mutual fund options | All mutual funds have costs No-load mutual funds > $40 No mutual fund screener Offers < 500 mutual fund options |
Benzinga Fintech Awards
Benzinga's Fintech Awards is the centralized hub for finding access to the best and brightest in the fintech space. As Benzinga evaluates companies to participate in the awards we look for innovative standouts and the value-driven impact these companies are creating for their users. We bring in guest judges that span multiple different business verticals that can see the long-term potential that these companies bring to their space.
We apply the listmakers and award winners to our content to further give credence to the value these platforms bring to our users.