Mortgage Broker vs. Direct Lender: What Sets Them Apart?

If you’re ready to buy a home, you might wonder whether you need a mortgage broker or a mortgage lender. While a mortgage broker will act as an intermediary and help you research the best mortgages available, they don’t offer the loan. A mortgage lender will offer the loan and hand over the check. This can be a bank or other financial institution. Read on to understand the key differences between mortgage brokers and lenders to understand how you could work with both to secure the best available mortgage rates.  

What Is a Mortgage Broker?

A mortgage broker is an intermediary who connects two parties for a common purpose at favorable terms for both. A mortgage broker works to help a borrower find a mortgage lender with favorable terms. This facilitates the mortgage process. With competitive mortgage markets, mortgage brokers have become essential for many borrowers. A mortgage broker typically works with multiple lenders to help borrowers get the best available rates. 

Pros of Working with a Mortgage Broker

A mortgage broker can provide access to a wide range of mortgage products from different lenders. Brokers often have extensive mortgage market knowledge and can guide borrowers through the application process. They can also save time and effort for borrowers by doing the legwork of researching mortgage options and comparing rates and terms.

If you want the best available rates but don’t know where to start, a mortgage broker can give you resources to secure a favorable mortgage. Even if you plan to work with a direct lender, researching the options through a mortgage broker can offer better available terms and give you leverage in negotiations.

Cons of Working with a Mortgage Broker

While there are many advantages to working with a mortgage broker, some brokers may have limited lender relationships or may prioritize lenders that offer higher commissions. Likewise, relying solely on a broker can mean missing out on the opportunity to research and negotiate directly with lenders. In addition, borrowers may need to pay broker fees or higher interest rates to compensate the broker for their services. 

For that reason, if you’re willing to do some legwork to research the best available options, you could secure a more favorable mortgage than a broker. Likewise, if you want to work with a specific lender, such as a local bank or credit union, you could be better off negotiating directly with that lender. 

What Is a Direct Lender?

A direct or mortgage lender is a financial institution or mortgage bank offering and underwriting home loans. This includes any bank, credit union or mortgage lender offering loans directly to borrowers. When securing a mortgage, you always have the option to work with a direct lender instead of going through a mortgage broker.

Direct lenders have set borrowing guidelines that borrowers must meet to verify creditworthiness and ability to repay a loan. A direct lender will set the terms, interest rate, repayment schedule and other mortgage terms. 

Pros of Working with a Direct Lender

Working with a direct lender has numerous advantages. Most notably, borrowers can directly communicate with the lender, allowing for a smoother and more personalized lending process. Direct lenders may also have more flexibility in loan options and requirements. Working with a direct lender often results in faster mortgage processing and closing times.

When you work with a direct lender for the mortgage application, you can negotiate personalized mortgage terms with the loan officer. You can get customized service and the experience of working directly with your mortgage lender. You can also compare direct lenders with online mortgage lenders to ensure you get the best available terms. 

Cons of Working with a Direct Lender

For many borrowers, working with a direct lender is challenging. Lenders have a strict approval process. Working with a lender may involve high fees and closing costs. Lenders may also require borrowers to purchase private mortgage insurance (PMI) if they have a down payment of less than 20%. 

Borrowers with low savings for a downpayment, a lower credit score or unstable income can have difficulty qualifying for a mortgage with a direct lender. 

Mortgage Broker vs. Lender: Major Differences

Should you work with a mortgage broker or a direct lender? Understanding the major differences can help guide your decision-making. 

Options Available

A mortgage broker and a direct lender differ in the options available. You can compare them. 

A mortgage broker typically has a group of lenders they work with. Many brokers are partial to certain lenders, which could limit the choices they offer you. You also could choose to work directly with any lender, including online banks, brick-and-mortar banks or credit unions. 

Rates and Fees

A mortgage broker and a direct lender differ in rates and fees. Which one is more costly varies. A mortgage broker may charge more fees upfront or higher interest rates to compensate for their services. They also may be able to secure lower interest rates, which makes any upfront fees worth it in the long term. 

To determine whether a mortgage broker or lender offers better terms, you’ll want to compare both and read the fine print to understand specific offers. 

Personalized Service

A mortgage broker and a direct lender differ in terms of personalized service. While a direct lender such as a local bank or credit union is known for personalized service from a loan officer, a mortgage broker can find offers personalized to your financial situation. 

Time and Efficiency

A mortgage broker and a direct lender can maximize your time and efficiency. If you're short on time to research the best available mortgage lenders, a mortgage broker could save you time. 

If you have a lower credit score, high debt or other financial situations that can make securing a loan more challenging, a mortgage broker could save you time by connecting you with lenders willing to offer you a mortgage. 

Cost

A mortgage broker and a direct lender differ in cost, depending on the fees they build into the closing and long-term interest rates. Usually, mortgage brokers are paid on a fee-based schedule. Often, the bank’s loan origination fee is paid to the broker. This amount is linked to the total amount of the loan. 

Direct lenders charge various fees to cover their costs. This includes a loan origination fee as well as the interest rate on the loan principal. Direct lenders may also charge for private mortgage insurance, late fees or other fees. All lenders must provide a good faith estimate (GFE) to give you an idea of the expected total costs. 

Find the Best Mortgage Lenders From Benzinga's Top Providers

Should You Choose a Mortgage Broker vs. Lender?

Securing the best mortgage rates can have a long-term impact on your financial health, helping you save thousands over the life of the loan. For many borrowers, it’s not a question of mortgage broker vs. lender but how to use both to find the best available terms for your financial situation. Ready to get started? Find the best online mortgage lenders or mortgage lenders for self-employed borrowers here.

Frequently Asked Questions