VTSAX vs VFIAX

Quick Answer: VTSAX and VFIAX differ in the number of companies and the types of companies that they hold in their portfolios.

Benzinga compares these two index funds, providing insights into which one performs better. Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Admiral Shares (VTSAX) and Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares (VFIAX) are well-regarded Vanguard index funds. Index funds closely follow a set benchmark and can be constructed as mutual or exchange-traded funds (ETF). Although distinctly different, the two index mutual funds offer similarities that may benefit many investors. Compare and research the two index funds before investing.

What is VTSAX?

VTSAX, or Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Admiral Shares, is a large-blend mutual fund. It tracks the performance of the entire U.S. stock market. This fund has a significant investment in technology stocks. However, it also provides broad diversification across sectors like financials, healthcare, and consumer discretionary. This diversification helps reduce the risk associated with any single sector. While VTSAX is considered riskier than some other index funds, it offers potential for higher long-term returns. Historically, the fund has shown strong annual performance. This makes it a popular choice for investors seeking growth in a low-cost and diversified investment option.

Why Should You Invest in VTSAX?

Investing in VTSAX, the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Admiral Shares, can build wealth over time. It offers broad diversification across thousands of U.S. stocks. The fund includes small, mid, and large-cap companies. Its goal is to match the performance of the CRSP US Total Market Index. This helps investors benefit from overall economic growth. VTSAX has low expense ratios, making it a cost-effective option. As a passively managed index fund, it simplifies investing compared to actively managed funds. This introduction will highlight the key benefits of VTSAX for both beginners and experienced investors.

Broad Market Exposure

VTSAX provides broad exposure to the entire U.S. stock market, which includes thousands of individual companies from various sectors and market capitalizations—spanning large-cap companies like Apple and Microsoft to smaller, more volatile companies that may offer greater growth potential. By investing in VTSAX, you are effectively owning a small share of the overall U.S. economy. This extensive diversification can help minimize the risks associated with investing in individual stocks, as the performance of any one stock will have a lesser effect on your overall portfolio.

Low Costs

One of the main advantages of VTSAX is its low expense ratio of 0.04%. This means you would pay only $4 in annual fees for every $10,000 invested. Low fees can greatly impact the growth of your investment over time. In contrast, actively managed funds often charge much higher fees. These higher fees can reduce your overall returns. Vanguard focuses on keeping costs low. This approach helps ensure that a larger portion of your money is invested. As a result, your investment can potentially generate higher returns through compounding.

Strong Long-Term Performance

The U.S. stock market has historically provided steady returns over long periods. VTSAX aims to replicate that performance. It tracks the CRSP U.S. Total Market Index, reflecting the overall market’s growth and trends. Short-term market fluctuations are normal. However, VTSAX’s focus on the entire market allows it to benefit from the long-term upward trend of the U.S. economy. For long-term investors with a time horizon of 10 years or more, VTSAX is a reliable option. It captures market gains with relatively low effort. This makes it a suitable choice for retirement or general wealth-building goals.

What is VFIAX?

VFIAX, or the Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares, is a low-cost investment option. It tracks the performance of the S&P 500, which includes 500 of the largest publicly traded companies, mainly based and operating out of the U.S. This large-blend index fund provides exposure to many industries, such as technology, healthcare, financial, and consumer discretionary. Major holdings include leading technology companies like Meta Platforms Inc. (NASDAQ: FB) and Apple Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL). The fund also features significant investments across other sectors, which creates a well-rounded portfolio. VFIAX’s diversification helps reduce risk by spreading investments across various companies and industries. It is a popular choice for investors looking for steady growth over the long term with moderate risk due to its broad market exposure.

Why Should You Invest in VFIAX?

Investing in VFIAX, the Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares, is a solid choice for all investors. This fund aims to match the S&P 500's performance, which includes 500 large U.S. companies. It provides broad market exposure and a diversified portfolio. VFIAX has low fees and strong historical returns. It is meant for long-term growth, making it attractive for passive investors. Investing in VFIAX reduces the risks of picking individual stocks. It aligns your investments with the overall market performance. Knowing the benefits of VFIAX can help with your investment choices.

Diversification Across Leading U.S. Companies

VFIAX tracks the S&P 500 Index, giving investors access to 500 large and established U.S. companies across various sectors like technology, healthcare, finance, and consumer goods. This diversification helps lower the risks linked to individual stock investments and offers extensive market coverage, which may contribute to more stable returns over time.

Low Expense Ratio for Cost Efficiency

A key advantage of VFIAX is its low expense ratio of 0.04%. This makes it more affordable than many actively managed funds, which usually charge higher fees that can reduce returns over time. For investors looking to invest for the long term, reducing fees is important, as even minor savings can accumulate into significant wealth over the years.

Strong Historical Performance

The S&P 500 Index, which is tracked by VFIAX, has a history of showing consistent growth. On average, the index has returned about 10% annually (before inflation), which makes it a dependable choice for investors looking for steady market growth. Although past performance does not ensure future results, the fund's emphasis is placed primarily upon large, stable companies, which provides a solid basis for ongoing returns, particularly for those with a long-term investment strategy.

VTSAX vs VFIAX: Key Similarities

VTSAX (Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund) and VFIAX (Vanguard 500 Index Fund) share key similarities. Both are popular choices for long-term stock market growth. They use passive investment strategies and have low expense ratios. Vanguard supports both funds and has an investor-friendly approach. Each fund aims to match its benchmark's performance and provides diversification through various stocks. Despite having different investment goals, these common traits can assist investors in selecting the right options for their portfolios.

Type of Investment

VTSAX and VFIAX are popular index mutual funds from Vanguard. They provide broad market exposure at low costs. VTSAX covers the entire U.S. stock market. It includes large, mid, and small-cap companies. VFIAX focuses on the S&P 500 Index. This index features 500 of the largest U.S. companies, primarily large-cap stocks. VTSAX offers wider exposure but may be more volatile. It also has higher potential returns. VFIAX is generally more stable due to its focus on large-cap stocks. Both funds have low expense ratios, making them good for long-term investors. VTSAX is best for those wanting complete market coverage. VFIAX is suited for investors who prefer blue-chip companies.

Market-Cap-Weighted

Both VTSAX and VFIAX are market-cap-weighted funds. In this approach, stocks are weighted by their total market value. Larger companies, like Apple and Microsoft, affect performance more than smaller ones. This method reflects the size and significance of companies in the market. It helps the fund's performance match the overall stock market or its index. Market-cap weighting allows investors to focus on established companies. However, it can also make the fund highly sensitive to the performance of the largest firms.

Similar Holdings

VFIAX and VTSAX focus on large-cap U.S. companies. Both funds list Apple Inc. and Microsoft Corp. as their largest holdings. These tech companies are significant due to their large market capitalizations. However, their portfolios differ. VFIAX includes only the 500 largest U.S. companies from the S&P 500 Index, focusing solely on large-cap stocks. VTSAX, on the other hand, tracks the entire U.S. stock market and includes thousands of stocks. This means VTSAX also invests in small- and mid-cap companies that VFIAX does not. Overall, VTSAX offers a wider range of investments, while VFIAX focuses on the largest firms.

Low Turnover Rate

Both VFIAX and VTSAX have low turnover rates. This helps investors save on transaction costs and taxes. A low turnover means the funds hold their investments longer. As of December 2023, both funds reported turnover rates under 5%. This indicates a buy-and-hold strategy. Low turnover is common in index funds. They aim to match benchmark performance without frequent trading. By keeping turnover low, VFIAX and VTSAX allow investors to retain more returns. Lower trading costs enhance overall performance. Additionally, less turnover can reduce taxes. With fewer capital gains, investors may have lower tax bills. This makes these funds more tax-efficient. This strategy aligns with passive investing, which emphasizes long-term growth.

ETF Equivalents

Both VTSAX and VFIAX have corresponding ETFs: VTI for VTSAX and VOO for VFIAX. These ETFs provide similar exposure to the same assets. ETFs offer more flexibility than mutual funds. You can buy and sell them throughout the trading day at market prices. This allows investors to react quickly to market changes. ETFs also typically have lower expense ratios, saving money over time.Both VTI and VOO provide good diversification and low turnover, similar to their mutual fund counterparts. They also offer strategic trading options like limit and stop-loss orders. Additionally, ETFs are usually more tax-efficient due to fewer capital gains distributions. Having ETF options for VTSAX and VFIAX helps investors choose the best tool for their investment strategies while still tracking the underlying indices.

VTSAX vs VFIAX: Key Differences

When building a diverse investment portfolio, two popular mutual funds are often considered: Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund Admiral Shares (VTSAX) and Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares (VFIAX). Both funds are managed by Vanguard. They aim to give investors broad exposure to the stock market, but they have different strategies. VTSAX seeks to mimic the entire U.S. stock market, including small-, mid-, and large-cap stocks. This approach provides wider diversification. In contrast, VFIAX focuses only on the 500 largest U.S. companies. It offers a concentrated view of large-cap stocks that have a history of strong performance. These differences affect risk, potential returns, and costs. Investors should understand each fund's features to meet their investment goals.

Many Believe VFIAX will Outperform VTSAX

Warren Buffett mentioned that he believes that indexes that track the S&P 500 have excellent growth potential. VFIAX closely tracks the S&P 500 and may have the potential to slightly outperform VTSAX in the future.

VTSAX is a Little More Flexible

VTSAX is more flexible than VFIAX. It is an index fund that includes the entire U.S. stock market. This means it covers large, mid, and small-cap companies. Investors can access many opportunities. VTSAX generally has a lower price per share. This makes it easier for investors with limited capital to enter the market. Unlike VFIAX, VTSAX does not require a large initial investment. This affordability helps investors adjust their investment amounts. They can use strategies like dollar-cost averaging to reduce the effects of market volatility. Overall, VTSAX offers competitive pricing and diverse exposure. It is a good choice for those who want to optimize their portfolios and maintain flexibility.

Long-term Investing Can Favor VTSAX

VTSAX has shown potential for long-term investors who can tolerate risks and handle market fluctuations for the chance of better returns. While previous performance does not guarantee future results, it has experienced growth of over 200% since its launch, reflecting the general upward trend of the U.S. stock market. This historical performance, along with its diverse exposure to various sectors and companies in the total stock market, makes it an attractive option for those looking to build wealth over the long term, as long as they are aware of the risks involved in equity investing.

VTSAX vs VFIAX: Top Ten Holdings

Here are the top ten holdings for each index fund. 

VTSAX

1. Microsoft Corporation (6.22%)
2. Apple Inc. (5.40%)
3. NVIDIA Corporation (3.75%)
4. Amazon.com, Inc. (3.33%)
5. Meta Platforms, Inc. (2.20%)
6. Alphabet Inc. (1.66%)
7. Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (1.47%)
8. Alphabet Inc. (1.38%)
9. Eli Lilly and Company (1.30%)
10.  Broadcom Inc. (1.17%)

Source: VTSAX Holdings

VFIAX

1. Microsoft Corporation (7.18%)
2. Apple Inc. (6.17%)
3. NVIDIA Corporation (4.56%)
4. Amazon.com, Inc. (3.75%)
5. Meta Platforms, Inc. (2.54%)
6. Alphabet Inc. (1.91%)
7. Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (1.74%)
8. Alphabet Inc. (1.63)%
9. Eli Lilly and Company (1.40%)
10.  Broadcom Inc. (1.33%)

Source: VFIAX Holdings 

Choosing the Right Index Fund for You

Trying to decide between VTSAX vs VFIAX? It boils down to your investment goals and risk tolerance. Here's a breakdown to help you choose:

Growth Potential & Diversification

VTSAX tracks the entire US market, including smaller companies. This means potentially higher returns and more diversification, but also slightly more ups and downs (volatility).

Stability & Proven Performance

VFIAX sticks to the S&P 500, which includes the biggest US companies. This offers a more stable investment with a solid track record, but potentially lower growth compared to VTSAX.

Fees

Both funds have low fees, but VFIAX has a slight edge here.

Benefits of Index Funds

Index funds tend to offer lower fees as well as certain tax benefits. The low fees follow the logic that index funds closely follow a set benchmark, which takes out the need for extensive research or analysis. 

Lower fees are also a result of passive management, which means select index funds such as ETFs require less active management than other more actively managed investments. ETFs differ from mutual funds because ETFs offer more flexibility. For example, ETFs are traded similarly to stocks and can be purchased and sold during trading hours, which makes them more liquid. In addition, ETFs can be more tax-efficient, which might prove beneficial for an investor. 

Because of the extensive amount of diversification offered in an index fund, they also are better guarded against risk. Diversification allows index funds to contain a wider variety of investments. Index funds tend to track various assets while noting their performance as a group. 

In addition, index funds offer excellent value for long-term investing. Index funds often offer interest and dividends that provide consistent growth over an extended period. Index funds can be beneficial for holding over an extended period because they are closely linked with the market. Given time, the market tends to grow and increase, which works in the favor of index funds that are held over time. In general, index funds tend to average larger annual returns while also offering a certain level of risk protection. 

Frequently Asked Questions