The Grandmother of Value Investing

Everybody knows that Benjamin Graham was the father of value investing. He was the first set down for the public the idea of buying stocks and bonds when they traded at a discount to their real value. His writings are still used as the primary text for value investors around the world. His classroom at Columbia has produced some of the greatest investors in the history of the markets. Investors who were taught the craft by Grahams students have also done very well over the years and some of the top performing investment managers today can trace their heritage back to Graham's classroom. Most investors today are not aware that the idea of value investing also has something of a grandmother. Hetty Green will never be taken as the warm cuddly grandmother of fairy tales as by most accounts she was not a very nice person. She was extremely litigious and was constantly suing people who crossed her is some fashion of another. She took tax evasion to a whole new level and went out of her way to avoid income taxes. She once pulled a gun on an investor who threatened her son. She was also a notorious pinch penny who rarely turned on the heat or hot water to save money and once refused to have an operation to treat a hernia because it would cost $150.She came to be known as the Witch of Wall Street but none the less was one of the very first value investors. She was a wildly successful value investor as well. She took her inheritance of about $5 million ad invested very wisely. By the time she died she had accumulated more than $100 million in liquid assets and a portfolio of land, property and other assets that were held in different names to avoid taxation. Her tax evasion schemes make it almost impossible to know the total value of her fortune but we do know that when her daughter died in 1951 her half of Hetty's fortune was worth more than $200 million. She was thought to be the richest woman in the world when she died in 1916. She described the secret of her investment success by saying “There is no great secret in fortune making. All you do is buy cheap and sell dear, act with thrift and shrewdness and be persistent.” Her investment philosophy was pretty simple. She invested conservatively most of the time and held back lots of cash. When markets crashed she very calm and coolly rushed in to be a buyer. She would then hold until the boom times returned to the market at which time she would be a seller. She once described her approach telling a reporter “When I see a thing, going cheap because nobody wants it, I buy a lot of it and tuck it away. Then, when the time comes, they have to hunt me up and pay me a good price for my holdings.” She was astute and recognizing when things had gone too far and had no reluctance to liquidate stocks when they are too high in price She was not much of the idea of buy and hold forever investing. She once said that “"I never buy anything just to hold it. There is a price on everything I have. When that price is offered, I sell.” Hetty Green built a fortune by taking advantage of stock market extremes and taking a more conservative approach when the opportunity was not clear and obvious. She didn't trade in and out of the markets on a regular basis and was not interested in making a few percentage points guessing the short term direction of a particular stock. When the world seemed ot be falling apart and panic covered Wall Street she was a big buyer of stocks. When the part was booming and everyone else was buying she would sell them the stocks she purchased in the last decline for many times her purchase price. The Wicked Witch of Wall Street lived that “More money is made in the end by an over-supply of caution than by indiscriminate recklessness.” That approach is the forerunner of what Ben Graham would eventually label a margin of safety. She may not have been a very nice woman but she was an incredibly smart one. Hetty Green is the grandmother of value investing. Investors would be wise to follow her approach to market profits instead of trying the impossible task of day trading your way to fame and fortune.