Judge Dismisses ConsenSys Lawsuit After SEC Withdraws Ethereum Investigation

ConsenSys, the blockchain company behind Ethereum ETH/USD infrastructure projects like MetaMask, has faced a setback in its lawsuit against the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

What Happened: The company had initially sued the SEC for overreach, accusing the regulator of conducting an unnecessary investigation into Ethereum, specifically targeting Ethereum 2.0.

The lawsuit, filed earlier this year, sought to clarify that Ethereum's native token, ether, should not be classified as a security.

However, a Texas judge ruled that the lawsuit lacked merit due to the SEC's decision to abandon its Ethereum probe. In his decision, Judge Reed O'Connor of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas explained, "because withholding consideration subjects plaintiff to scant, if any, hardship, the claim lacks a ripe case or controversy.”

Essentially, the court found that without an active investigation, ConsenSys had no grounds to pursue the lawsuit.

This ruling follows the SEC's quiet closure of its Ethereum investigation earlier this year.

ConsenSys celebrated this development, stating in a post on X (formerly Twitter): "In a significant win for the industry, the SEC dropped its ‘Ethereum 2.0’ investigation after our litigation was filed, and the Texas court today recognized that the SEC already gave ConsenSys the relief it sought on that critical issue for the Ethereum ecosystem."

Also Read: Oops! Arthur Hayes Realizes $790,000 Loss On This Ethereum-Based Altcoin

Why IT Matters: While the SEC hasn't officially commented on the judge's decision or the case’s dismissal, the outcome reflects broader concerns within the blockchain industry regarding regulatory overreach.

ConsenSys maintained that their lawsuit had "laid bare the overzealous investigation of Ethereum," and it echoed widespread unease over the SEC's aggressive stance on blockchain software development.

Initially, ConsenSys had sought legal recognition that ETH is not a security and that its flagship product, MetaMask, does not function as a broker under federal law.

Moreover, the company argued that its staking services did not violate securities regulations.

Yet, while the Ethereum investigation has been dropped, the SEC followed up with charges in June, accusing ConsenSys of operating MetaMask as an unregistered securities broker.

Despite these charges, the SEC has remained relatively quiet about Ether's legal status. However, the regulator recently reached a settlement with trading platform eToro, allowing it to continue listing ETH in the U.S.

What’s Next: On November 19, these issues, along with the future of Ethereum and other crypto projects, will take center stage at Benzinga's highly anticipated Future of Digital Assets event, where key players in the blockchain space will gather to discuss the intersection of regulation, technology, and innovation.

Read Next:

• Bitcoin’s Correction Ends, But It Has To Break This Target To Surge To $70K: 10x Research

Image: Shutterstock