Benzinga

España
Italia
대한민국
日本
Français
Benzinga Edge
Benzinga Research
Benzinga Pro

  • Get Benzinga Pro
  • Data & APIs
  • Events
  • Premarket
  • Advertise
Contribute
España
Italia
대한민국
日本
Français

Benzinga

  • Premium Services
  • Financial News
    Latest
    Earnings
    Guidance
    Dividends
    M&A
    Buybacks
    Interviews
    Management
    Offerings
    IPOs
    Insider Trades
    Biotech/FDA
    Politics
    Healthcare
    Small-Cap
  • Markets
    Pre-Market
    After Hours
    Movers
    ETFs
    Options
    Cryptocurrency
    Commodities
    Bonds
    Futures
    Mining
    Real Estate
    Volatility
  • Ratings
    Analyst Color
    Downgrades
    Upgrades
    Initiations
    Price Target
  • Investing Ideas
    Trade Ideas
    Long Ideas
    Short Ideas
    Technicals
    Analyst Ratings
    Analyst Color
    Latest Rumors
    Whisper Index
    Stock of the Day
    Best Stocks & ETFs
    Best Penny Stocks
    Best S&P 500 ETFs
    Best Swing Trade Stocks
    Best Blue Chip Stocks
    Best High-Volume Penny Stocks
    Best Small Cap ETFs
    Best Stocks to Day Trade
    Best REITs
  • Money
    Investing
    Cryptocurrency
    Mortgage
    Insurance
    Yield
    Personal Finance
    Forex
    Startup Investing
    Real Estate Investing
    Prop Trading
    Credit Cards
    Stock Brokers
Research
My Stocks
Tools
Free Benzinga Pro Trial
Calendars
Analyst Ratings Calendar
Conference Call Calendar
Dividend Calendar
Earnings Calendar
Economic Calendar
FDA Calendar
Guidance Calendar
IPO Calendar
M&A Calendar
Unusual Options Activity Calendar
SPAC Calendar
Stock Split Calendar
Trade Ideas
Free Stock Reports
Insider Trades
Trade Idea Feed
Analyst Ratings
Unusual Options Activity
Heatmaps
Free Newsletter
Government Trades
Perfect Stock Portfolio
Easy Income Portfolio
Short Interest
Most Shorted
Largest Increase
Largest Decrease
Calculators
Margin Calculator
Forex Profit Calculator
100x Options Profit Calculator
Screeners
Stock Screener
Top Momentum Stocks
Top Quality Stocks
Top Value Stocks
Top Growth Stocks
Compare Best Stocks
Best Momentum Stocks
Best Quality Stocks
Best Value Stocks
Best Growth Stocks
Connect With Us
facebookinstagramlinkedintwitteryoutubeblueskymastodon
About Benzinga
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Market Resources
  • Advanced Stock Screener Tools
  • Options Trading Chain Analysis
  • Comprehensive Earnings Calendar
  • Dividend Investor Calendar and Alerts
  • Economic Calendar and Market Events
  • IPO Calendar and New Listings
  • Market Outlook and Analysis
  • Wall Street Analyst Ratings and Targets
Trading Tools & Education
  • Benzinga Pro Trading Platform
  • Options Trading Strategies and News
  • Stock Market Trading Ideas and Analysis
  • Technical Analysis Charts and Indicators
  • Fundamental Analysis and Valuation
  • Day Trading Guides and Strategies
  • Live Investor Events
  • Pre-market Stock Analysis and News
  • Cryptocurrency Market Analysis and News
Ring the Bell

A newsletter built for market enthusiasts by market enthusiasts. Top stories, top movers, and trade ideas delivered to your inbox every weekday before and after the market closes.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Data/Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Service Status
  • Sitemap
© 2026 Benzinga | All Rights Reserved
April 18, 2017 8:35 AM 5 min read

Running America The Corporate Way: Welfare Vs. Profit Maximization

by Shanthi Rexaline Benzinga Editor
Follow
PYPL Logo
PYPLPayPal Holdings Inc
$40.42-%
Overview

Most nations have modeled themselves after the concept of welfare state, a form of governance where a state is vested with the responsibility of tending to the needs of the economic and social well-being of the people.

A Welfare State

This term is supposed to have originated in Germany in the 19th century, when Otto von Bismarck, the first German chancellor, modeled his government on the concept. The most salient features of a welfare state, are, according to Britannica:

Juxtaposed with the concept of the welfare state is the profit motive — the principle on which business is built. Businesses strive to consistently grow profit and, in the process, generate maximum returns to shareholders.

Will Profit Motive Work For A Nation?

Running the federal government as a business, with the president acting as a CEO, isn't feasible, a professor of legal studies in business ethics at Wharton, Peter Conti-Brown, a professor of legal studies in business ethics at Wharton, said during a recent podcast.

"The instinct to want to have market structures, incentive-based compensation, command-and-control approaches to government as we see in business can come from anyone who's gone and spent too much time at the DMV," Conti-Brown said.

"It's like, 'Oh, this is miserable. If this were privately run, this would be very different.' But virtually nothing about the architecture of government, in the United States or in other places, corresponds to that model. Your interactions with Congress, your interactions with the public, with foreign countries, the entire fiscal dynamic, budgetary dynamics differ widely between public sector and private sector."

Has The Clamor For Corporatization Come Only With Trump?

A Washington Post article quotes many past instances of people wanting to run politics as a business:

A Precedent For Trump

When President Donald Trump, who hasn't had prior experience in politics, promised during his campaign that he would fix the federal government using his business acumen, it wasn't a groundbreaking statement.

These recommendations, according to the release, would be developed in collaboration with career staff along with private-sector and other external thought leaders. The initiative is to spearheaded by the president's son-in-law Jared Kushner, who has little political expertise, but who is expected to plunge headlong into a range of policy issues that may have been alien to him in his past experiences.

Executives And Political Takes

The business leaders Trump has been relying on have strong political stances of their own.

Peter Thiel, the cofounder of Paypal Holdings Inc (NASDAQ:PYPL), who was named to the executive committee of Trump's transition team in November, is a self-confessed opponent of regulations.

Trump has critics among corporate leaders as well. Shark Tank's Mark Cuban recently retweeted a Talking Points Memo article that was anything but bullish on Trump: 

Related Links:
Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs

© 2026 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.

To add Benzinga News as your preferred source on Google, click here.


Posted In:
EducationEmerging MarketsPoliticsGlobalTop StoriesMarketsGeneralDonald TrumpJared KushnerMark CubanPeter ThielRonald Reagan
  • The state should be based on the principles of equality of opportunity.
  • There should be equitable distribution of wealth.
  • It should be responsible for providing everyone with at least the minimal provisions of a good life, such as basic education, health services and housing.
  • A fundamental feature of the welfare state in most advanced industrialized countries is the provision of social security, as it is called in the United States.
  • Franklin MacVeagh, who was appointed as treasury secretary by former President William Taft, said in 1909 that he was making an effort to run the Treasury like a business — and added that the department "sadly needs it, as nearly all the offices of the government do."
  • The article quotes Fiorello La Guardia, New York's mayor in 1938, as saying: "I seek to run [the government] as any honest man attempts to run his business and to live within my revenue."
  • In 1961, New York governor Nelson Rockefeller pronounced that big government was "here to stay" — but that the state needed to run more like a big business.
  • In 1978, Fob James, who ran for governor of Alabama, and later in 1981, John Brown, former Kentucky governor, pledged to run their respective states as a business.
  • In 1992, third-party presidential candidate Ross Perot pitched his election campaign on the premise "like a business."

Trump is arguably seeking to run the government like the private sector. In late March, Trump announced that the White House Office of American Innovation would make recommendations concerning improvement of government operations and services, quality of life for Americans and job creation.

Some past administrations have also sought support from business leaders to streamline operations. One example, when former President Ronald Reagan formed the Grace Commission, with businessman Peter Grace at the helm, was cited by The Atlantic in a story about whether Trump can succeed in applying business principles to government.

How President Trump's Plans Will Affect Individual Income Taxes How Trump's Tax Policy Could Affect Large Companies Like Apple _______ Image Credit: "President Donald Trump attends a strategic and policy CEO discussion in the State Department Library in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building at the White House, Tuesday, April 11, 2017." By D. Myles Cullen - Photo of the Day: April 12, 2017 on whitehouse.gov, Public Domain, via Wikimedia Commons

PYPL Logo
PYPLPayPal Holdings Inc
$40.42-%
Overview
Comments
Loading...