Licensed But Closed: New York's Cannabis Dream Faces Bureaucratic Nightmare

New York’s dream of a thriving legal cannabis market for many licensed retailers remains just that – a dream, as the gap between the issued licenses and operational dispensaries widens alarmingly. 

The New York Office of Cannabis Management (OCM) has issued a total of 1,117 licenses, yet only about one-tenth of these businesses are operational, noted The Green Market Report. This disparity exposes significant issues, from bureaucratic red tape to legal hurdles, impeding the transition from an illicit market to a regulated framework.

Slow Dispensary Rollout Hampers Illicit Market Control

As of 2024, only 141 dispensaries have opened their doors, according to OCM data. This slow rollout impacts not only business owners but also hampers efforts to curb the sprawling illegal market, estimated to include around 3,000 unlicensed shops in New York City alone. This situation poses serious questions about the effectiveness of state strategies to replace illegal operations with lawful enterprises.

Challenges With Social Equity Licenses

Adding to the complexity, New York has initiated two types of social equity licenses: Conditional Adult-Use Retail Dispensary (CAURD) and Social Economic and Equity applicants (SEE). CAURD licenses are intended for individuals directly affected by past drug laws, whereas SEE licenses target broader impacted communities. Despite the good intentions, actual support for both of these programs, including funding and logistical assistance, has fallen far short of expectations.

CAURD Vs. SEE Licensees: Progress Diverges

Many CAURD licensees have not sought funding or engaged in location scouting, relying instead on anticipated state support, according to Britni Tantalo, president of the New York Cannabis Retail Association. This misplaced trust has significantly delayed the opening of their businesses, as the promised assistance has largely failed to materialize, leaving these license holders struggling to advance, notes The Green Market Report.

Meanwhile, the SEE license holders, with lower expectations of state aid, have moved more swiftly. Some have even begun selling their licenses, a possibility not afforded to CAURD licensees due to restrictions aimed at preventing a secondary market.

NY Landlords Struggle With Cannabis Shop Crackdowns

The situation is further complicated by ongoing enforcement efforts. Following an unsuccessful attempt to impose fines, New York City has started a more aggressive crackdown on unlicensed cannabis shops known as “Operation Padlock to Protect.” Over 400 stores have been closed, leaving landlords grappling with the aftermath of evictions and lost rental income. This aggressive enforcement is part of a broader strategy by Governor Kathy Hochul's administration, which recently saw a reshuffle at the top of the OCM to intensify these efforts.

Ultimately, while New York has made strides in diversifying its cannabis licensing, the gap between the potential and reality of New York's cannabis market continues to be an unresolved puzzle.

Photo courtesy of OCM.

Read Next:

• NYC Authorities Dismantle Million-Dollar Illicit Cannabis Operation In Brooklyn

Cannabis rescheduling seems to be right around the corner. Want to understand what this means for the future of the industry? Hear directly for top executives, investors and policymakers at the 19th Benzinga Cannabis Capital Conference, coming to Chicago this Oct. 8-9. Get your tickets now before prices surge by following this link.