A Tale Of Two Trumps: Clemency For Some, Death For Others In His Drug Policy Approach

U.S. President Donald Trump announced last week that he has appointed Alice Marie Johnson, a Tennessee woman whose drug-related life sentence he commuted in 2018, as his “pardon czar.” The move comes as Trump simultaneously calls for the death penalty for drug dealers, creating a striking contrast in his approach to criminal justice.

A Redemption Story Turned Policy Role

Alice Johnson, a Tennessee grandmother and first-time nonviolent offender, spent more than two decades in prison before being granted clemency by Trump in 2018, following high-profile advocacy from Kim Kardashian. In 2020, she received a full pardon, and since then, she has been an outspoken advocate for criminal justice reform.

Trump made the announcement at a Black History Month reception at the White House, roughly four weeks after he returned to office. He stated that Johnson would advise him on cases where pardons were warranted. Trump praised Johnson's transformation, saying, “Alice was in prison for doing something that today probably wouldn’t even be prosecuted.”

A Hardline Stance On Drug Crimes And Unclear Cannabis Policy

While Trump is elevating a former drug convict to oversee pardons, he is simultaneously pushing for the most extreme penalties for drug-related offenses. He has repeatedly called for Congress to pass legislation imposing the death penalty for drug traffickers, arguing that such measures are “very humane” and would serve as a deterrent to crime.

Also read: Brittney Griner Cancels Cannabis Keynote After Finding Disturbing Hotel Room Message

According to Marijuana Moment, Trump told governors at a White House event, “If you notice that every country that has the death penalty has no drug problem. They execute drug dealers.” He added, “And when you think about it, it's very humane, because every drug dealer, on average they say, kills at least 500 people—not to mention the damage they do so many others.” However, there is no publicly available data or research to support Trump’s claim that each drug dealer is responsible for 500 deaths, and fact-checking organizations have found no credible evidence backing this statistic.

During a meeting with U.S. governors, Trump encouraged state leaders to consider implementing harsher penalties for drug offenses. In addition, his administration is preparing to launch a nationwide anti-drug advertising campaign aimed at deterring substance use, with a budget expected to be between $100 million and $200 million.

Additionally, Trump has ordered a reinstatement of the federal death penalty, which, according to research disproportionately impacts incarcerated Black Americans.

Meanwhile, Trump's stance on cannabis reform remains unclear. Before the election, he signaled openness to rescheduling and even potential legalization in Florida. However, his appointments and recent rhetoric suggest a return to more conservative drug policies, leaving the cannabis industry uncertain about the administration's direction.

A Policy Paradox?

The appointment of Alice Johnson as a clemency advisor while simultaneously advocating for the death penalty for drug traffickers presents a striking contradiction in Trump’s criminal justice approach. On the one hand, his administration highlights redemption and second chances, using Johnson as a powerful example. On the other, his policies push for extreme punishments for others convicted of drug-related crimes, raising concerns about fairness and consistency.

This contradiction leaves many questioning how justice is being applied. Johnson has long championed clemency for nonviolent drug offenders, but the administration’s broader stance suggests a return to the severe drug policies of the past. Critics argue that this duality sends mixed signals about whether Trump's criminal justice vision leans toward reform or punishment—an unresolved debate that is already fueling controversy among lawmakers, civil rights groups and the public.

Read next: EXCLUSIVE: Ex-Rep. Kinzinger On GOP’s Internal War Over Drug Policy, Cannabis, Psychedelics – ‘Quite Likely Legal In 5-10 Years’

Lead image via Shutterstock