After NFA's Coinbase Approval, Will SEC Ride The Same Crypto Wave?

In the dynamic world of digital assets, regulatory bodies are in a continuous race to keep up.

With the recent decision by the National Futures Association (NFA) to approve Coinbase Global Inc COIN as a Futures Commission Merchant (FCM), all eyes are now on the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Will the SEC align with the NFA's progressive stance, or will it carve its own path?

Richard Mico, the U.S. CEO, and chief legal officer of Banxa, a payment-and-compliance infrastructure provider, weighed in on the matter. "I’m cautiously optimistic about the state of regulation in the United States," he said. "The SEC has taken an approach widely seen as regulating by enforcement, generating concerns about a potential exodus of digital asset innovators to markets with clearer regulatory frameworks."

Mico highlighted the significance of major financial institutions like BlackRock BLK and Fidelity applying for spot BTC ETFs, viewing it as a validation of Bitcoin and the broader industry. 

Anthony Georgiades, a general partner at Innovating Capital, shared his perspective on the tumultuous regulatory landscape.

"This year has been a rollercoaster when it comes to crypto regulation in the U.S.," he stated.

Reflecting on the challenges faced by the industry, Georgiades mentioned the denial of banking services and the SEC's lawsuits against key players like Coinbase and Binance BNB/USD.

However, he also pointed to the Ripple XRP/USD ruling as a beacon of hope, emphasizing its implication that crypto assets are not fundamentally securities.

"The CFTC seems to agree with the digital asset industry in thinking that crypto assets are not inherently securities," he noted, referencing the CFTC's decision to allow Coinbase to engage in futures trading.

Terrence Yang, Managing Director at Swan Bitcoin, offered a more critical viewpoint. "Regulation and compliance continue to trend towards more aggressive enforcement," he observed.

Yang expressed skepticism about the SEC following the NFA's lead, explaining that the NFA's role as a self-regulatory organization (SRO) under the CFTC is distinct from the SEC's focus on securities law violations.

"Both Coinbase and Binance aided and abetted the pump and dump of 'digital penny stock' cryptocurrencies on US retail."

Yang also highlighted the SEC's reluctance to follow other countries with Bitcoin ETFs, such as Canada, Brazil, and Dubai.

Also Read: From Rags To Riches With A 16,000% Boom, But Is The Bubble About To Burst For 'The Biggest Memecoin On The Block'?

Will The SEC Follow Suit?

The million-dollar question now is whether the SEC will take inspiration from the NFA's recent move. There are a few factors to consider:

1. Market Evolution: The digital assets market has evolved significantly over the past few years. With major financial institutions and corporations showing interest in cryptocurrencies, the SEC might be prompted to revisit its stance.

2. Investor Protection: The SEC's primary mandate is to protect investors. As the digital asset ecosystem develops more robust security and transparency measures, the SEC might feel more comfortable easing certain restrictions or providing clearer guidelines.

3. Global Trends: Regulatory trends in major financial hubs around the world could influence the SEC's decisions. If leading economies adopt a more open approach to digital assets, the SEC might consider similar moves to ensure the U.S. remains competitive in the global financial arena.

While the NFA's decision to approve COIN as an FCM is undoubtedly a progressive step, it remains to be seen if the SEC will follow suit.

The evolving nature of the digital assets market, combined with global regulatory trends and the SEC's mandate to protect investors, will play crucial roles in shaping the future of digital asset regulations in the U.S.

Read Next: Fed's Rate Hike Signal Sends Bitcoin, Ethereum Into Tailspin

Join Benzinga's Future of Digital Assets in NYC on Nov. 14, 2023 to stay updated on trends like AI, regulations, SEC actions & institutional adoption in the crypto space. Secure early bird discounted tickets now!

Photo: Shutterstock