From Crisis To Comeback: FTX's Collapse And The Road To Redemption

The collapse of FTX Trading Ltd. in November took the cryptocurrency market by storm, shaking up the already fragile sector. 

Industry experts have referred to the crypto exchange's bankruptcy as its "Lehman moment," alluding to the historic 2008 collapse of Lehman Brothers Inc., which triggered a worldwide recession. FTX Founder Sam Bankman-Fried was sued by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which alleged that he engaged in a "massive, yearslong fraud."

Talks Of A Reboot 

In the aftermath of Bankman-Fried's arrest, attorney John Jay Ray III, who specializes in restructuring insolvent companies, took over FTX last November. Ray stated that "[FTX] has begun the process of soliciting interested parties to the reboot of the FTX.com exchange," despite significant hurdles arising from stricter regulatory oversight and the ongoing bankruptcy proceedings. A revival of FTX is being discussed with potential investors.  

Don’t Miss:

• Until 2016 it was illegal for retail investors to invest in high-growth startups. Thanks to changes in federal law, this Kevin O’Leary-Backed Startup Lets You Become a Venture Capitalist With $100
•  Don’t just buy from your favorite brands, own them so you own the upside. Learn how Retail Investors Are Taking Stakes In Their Favorite Startups To Own The Upside

The discussions include joint-venture arrangements and the possibility of compensating specific existing customers with a stake in the reorganized entity. People familiar with the matter said that Figure Technologies, a blockchain technology company, has expressed interest in supporting the revival of FTX. 

Despite the regulatory challenges and criminal fraud allegations against FTX, Ray stated in January that customers and stakeholders believed in the fundamental viability of FTX's business model, prompting the establishment of a task force to explore the revival of the exchange.

To stay updated with top startup news & investments, sign up for Benzinga's Startup Investing & Equity Crowdfunding Newsletter.

Restructuring Requirements

The restart plan offers some hope for creditors, as reboots generally provide better outcomes compared to liquidation. For FTX, reviving the exchange is crucial for the distribution of FTT tokens, the platform's in-house token used by customers for transactions and trading. Without a restart, the FTT tokens may become worthless. FTX still needs to resolve its dispute with Bahamian liquidators who seized a substantial number of FTT tokens from the exchange's accounts.

The success of FTX's relaunch is also contingent on the recovery of approximately $11 billion worth of misspent customer funds, which could be used to reimburse customers who believed their funds were securely held by the exchange. After taking over, Ray launched a comprehensive investigation into FTX's activities that revealed new details of how customer funds were spent without their knowledge, including investments in companies like Robinhood Markets Inc. and Modulo Capital. Recovering the misappropriated funds has proven to be a challenge, with a forensic audit revealing $9 billion owed to customers.

FTX has been selling assets and attempting to recoup investments made with customer funds, but the value of many of the investments has declined significantly, creating additional obstacles to fund recovery. FTX recently received approval to sell LedgerX for a fraction of its original purchase price, and efforts to sell Embed are projected to yield minimal returns.

To stay updated with top startup news & investments, sign up for Benzinga's Startup Investing & Equity Crowdfunding Newsletter

The restructuring efforts, along with the associated litigation, have resulted in substantial costs for FTX. As of April, the company had accumulated approximately $200 million in professional fees, which are required to be paid before any distributions to compensate customers can occur. FTX plans to present a formal reorganization plan in July that is expected to include initial assessments of creditor compensation.

Thomas Braziel, a partner at 507 Capital, which invested in FTX after its bankruptcy, remains skeptical about the feasibility of restarting FTX because of recent regulatory actions against U.S. crypto companies and the significant damage to FTX's reputation.

"I find the restart of FTX a pretty tall order given the recent enforcement actions against U.S. crypto companies and the major reputational damage FTX has suffered," Braziel said. 

Navigating The Regulatory Challenges 

FTX's efforts to relaunch its flagship exchange come at a time when U.S. regulators are intensifying their crackdown on the cryptocurrency industry. Recent actions, such as the SEC's lawsuits against Binance and Coinbase for allegedly operating as unregistered securities exchanges, further complicate the regulatory landscape. 

Although many cryptocurrency exchanges operate in offshore jurisdictions, U.S. regulators can assert jurisdiction over foreign operations if there are connections to individuals or entities in the United States. This potential jurisdictional reach by the SEC could impact FTX's ability to operate — even if it restarts abroad and facilitates trades solely among non-Americans.

"Securities laws can be applied and enforced to the extent that there is a connection to people or entities based in the United States," said Todd Phillips, a fellow at the Roosevelt Institute think tank. "Even if FTX restarts abroad and is only facilitating trades between non-Americans, if the SEC determines that a token traded on the exchange is a U.S. security, that could impact its ability to operate."

See more on startup investing from Benzinga:

• There are more pounds of plastic in the ocean than pounds of fish. That’s why retail investors have invested over $4 million in This Startup That Invented Programmable, Drinkable Plastic That Dissolves In Water In 60 Hours
•  Gamers are selling their old gaming items for millions. Learn why everyday gamers and investors are claiming a stake in their side hustle and how they invested over $1.2 million in this startup.