Target Down 11% in 3 Months: Solid Bargain or Risky Bet?

Target Corporation TGT, a prominent player in the retail sector, has seen its stock price fall by 10.7% over the past three months. This decline can be traced to a mix of broader market dynamics and specific challenges faced by the company. Investors are currently divided on whether the stock is set for further decline or is on the verge of a recovery.

The stark contrast between Target's performance and that of its peers is evident when comparing it to the Zacks Retail–Discount Stores industry, which saw a gain of 11.7% during the same period. Additionally, the Zacks Retail-Wholesale sector and the S&P 500 Index increased by 5.4% and 10.4%, respectively. Target's close competitors, Costco Wholesale Corporation COST and Walmart Inc. WMT, have advanced 14% and 17.4%, respectively, in the same timeframe.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Currently trading well below its 52-week high of $181.86 achieved on Apr 1, 2024, Target's market value has diminished within a relatively brief timeframe. As of Jul 24, the stock closed at $146.45, marking a decline of approximately 19.5% from its highest point in the past year.

Moreover, Target's stock has fallen below critical technical thresholds, including its 50-day moving average of $149.36. This moving average is an important indicator for gauging market trends and momentum. The breach of this threshold heightens investor concerns about the stock's short-term outlook and signals the potential for further downside if these levels are not reclaimed.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Target Faces Uphill Battle

Target is navigating a tough economic landscape marked by shifting consumer preferences. The retail giant is grappling with significant challenges across multiple fronts, ranging from softness in key product categories to competitive pressures.

Recent performance has highlighted pronounced softness in discretionary categories, particularly Home and Hardlines. Sales in these segments continue to lag, with declines of 8.7% and 6.8%, respectively, in the first quarter of fiscal 2024. Despite efforts to cut costs and stimulate demand through price adjustments, consumer reluctance remains exacerbated by inflationary pressures. A shift in consumer spending toward services rather than in-home products further dampens sales prospects in these categories.

As a result, the first quarter saw Target's comparable sales decrease by 3.7%, marking the fourth consecutive quarter of decline. This drop was driven by underperformance in critical categories and cautious consumer spending. Additionally, both the number of transactions and the average transaction amount fell by 1.9%, while store-originated comparable sales dropped by 4.8%.

While Target has made strides in digital sales and customer engagement through initiatives like Target Circle, growth remains subdued relative to expectations. Intense competition in the digital marketplace, coupled with rising customer acquisition costs, poses ongoing challenges. The company's efforts to enhance digital capabilities are crucial but require sustained investment in a saturated market.

Underlying inflation and a high interest rate environment weigh heavily on consumer sentiment, impacting discretionary spending. Although the job market is relatively strong, consumer confidence remains subdued, affecting non-essential categories within Target's product lineup. This cautious outlook is mirrored in Target's conservative sales guidance, with management forecasting a modest increase of 0-2% in second-quarter comparable sales.

Additionally, Target's first-quarter results revealed a troubling trend in SG&A expenses, which increased by approximately 130 basis points year over year as a percentage of total revenues to 21.1%. This rise was driven by higher compensation and benefits costs for employees and increased marketing expenses related to the launch of Target Circle. If sales growth continues to be muted, these elevated SG&A costs could impact profitability.

Building Blocks for the Future

Target's stock has faced headwinds over the past three months, but the company is making strategic moves that could yield results in the long run. The focus on enhancing its digital shopping experience and investing in stores, combined with the expansion of same-day services, is poised to drive growth. Additionally, efforts to optimize supply-chain operations are expected to help improve margins.

Part of Target's aggressive growth strategy includes plans to add more than 300 new stores over the next decade, which aims to expand its market footprint and enhance customer accessibility. Significant investments in modernizing its supply chain, including the development of additional sortation centers, are intended to streamline operations and improve delivery efficiency.

Furthermore, Target's commitment to integrating advanced technologies such as AI and machine learning is set to enhance both customer interactions and operational efficiencies across its omnichannel platform. By August 2024, the company plans to introduce a new generative AI tool named Store Companion in nearly 2,000 stores.

Adding to these, Target has announced a strategic partnership with Shopify SHOP, a leading global e-commerce platform. This collaboration aims to expand Target Plus, Target's curated third-party digital marketplace, by incorporating a selection of popular merchants and their products from Shopify. This initiative will introduce consumers to new, on-trend products and brands, enhancing the shopping experience with more affordable and high-quality options.

Unlocking Value

Although Target's stock is currently trading at a discount compared to its industry peers, this valuation disparity might not be as favorable as it seems. The lower price could be indicative of underlying issues rather than representing a clear investment opportunity.

Target is currently trading at a discount to its historical and industry benchmarks. The stock has a forward 12-month P/E ratio of 14.81, which is below the median level of 15.18 scaled in the past year. This compares to the forward 12-month P/E ratio of 30.67 for the industry.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

How Are Estimates Faring?

Target is currently in a tough spot. In the past 30 days, the Zacks Consensus Estimate for earnings has been revised down by one cent, now standing at $9.31 for the current fiscal year and $10.50 for the next fiscal year.

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

Investor Guidance

Given the challenges and strategic initiatives, current and prospective investors should proceed cautiously. Existing investors may need to evaluate whether to hold or adjust their positions based on the company's ability to overcome its short-term difficulties and capitalize on its long-term strategies. New investors should weigh the potential benefits of Target's growth and technology investments against the ongoing operational and market challenges. Currently, Target stock carries a Zacks Rank #4 (Sell).

To read this article on Zacks.com click here.