'Should I Sell My Family Home Or Let My Brother Continue Living There For Free?' Dave Ramsey's Advice: 'Quit Enabling'

Deciding the future of a family home can be emotionally and financially complex, especially when the property becomes a point of contention between siblings. A recent discussion on The Ramsey Show sheds light on one such scenario.

Tony, a caller from Chicago, explained his dilemma: after his mother's passing, he and his brother inherited a $450,000 paid-off home. Tony is the executor of the estate, but he feels torn between selling the house – potentially leaving his brother without a place to live – or allowing him to remain there rent-free as he has for the past 15 years.

Don't Miss:

• The average American couple has saved this much money for retirement — How do you compare?
• Can you guess how many retire with a $5,000,000 nest egg? The percentage may shock you.
• CD Popularity Soars: Over 50 Million Americans Embrace Safe Savings with 5–10% Annual Growth

Dave Ramsey and co-host Jade Warshaw offered their perspectives, emphasizing financial responsibility, personal growth and the dangers of enabling unhealthy behavior.

Tony's brother, who struggles with anxiety and dependence on medication, doesn't have a job. His girlfriend, a part-time nurse and disabled veteran, pays his bills and has lived with him in the home for nearly a decade. Tony revealed his mother had allowed this arrangement out of compassion but admitted that continuing it feels unsustainable.

To complicate matters, Tony's father has been paying $1,400 a month to Tony's inheritance, intended as rent, to compensate for his brother occupying the home. Tony admitted he needed the money from selling the house and questioned whether letting his brother stay indefinitely was fair or beneficial.

See Also: ‘Scrolling To UBI' — Deloitte's #1 fastest-growing software company allows users to earn money on their phones. You can invest TODAY for just $0.26/share with a $1000 minimum.

Ramsey pointed out that he wouldn't just be throwing his brother out on the street. "He's gonna have $200,000," Ramsey said, referring to the half of the proceeds each sibling would receive from selling the home. Ramsey questioned the fairness of the brother expecting to live rent-free and argued that enabling this behavior would do more harm than good.

Ramsey recommended that Tony approach the situation with both firmness and compassion.

"You do have to deal with this lovingly and help him get better and sit down with him," he advised. "Help them deal with it and help them see a path of what they could do with the money from the house."

Warshaw agreed, stressing the practicality of selling the home. "Just because he's lived there for 15 years – it wasn't his house," she said. She added that there's nothing wrong with Tony telling his brother that he needs the money from the house and working out a plan forward. 

Trending: I’m 62 Years Old And Have $1.2 Million Saved. Is This Enough to Retire Stress-Free?

Ramsey also noted that legal steps might be necessary if Tony's brother refuses to cooperate. While this could strain their relationship, Ramsey emphasized the importance of setting boundaries.

Ramsey told Tony that if his brother reacts poorly to the discussion, Tony should contact a lawyer and take steps to evict him – and let his brother know that is going to happen. Ultimately, Ramsey said Tony needs to take proactive steps to end this dysfunction. 

Many families face challenges when navigating inheritance and shared assets. Ramsey advises balancing compassion with accountability, ensuring that financial decisions are practical and supportive of long-term growth for everyone involved.

If you're grappling with a similar situation, consider consulting a financial advisor or mediator to help you navigate the emotional and logistical complexities of family inheritance.

Read Next:

• Many are using this retirement income calculator to check if they’re on pace — here’s a breakdown on what’s behind this formula.
• Studies show 50% of consumers think Financial Advisors cost much more than they do — to debunk this, this company provides matching for free and a complimentary first call with the matched advisor.