Dave Ramsey To 47-Year-Old Caller: "Fire Your Tax Advisor" After He Was Told To Switch From A Roth To A Traditional 401(k) For Tax Deduction

If you've ever listened to The Ramsey Show, you know Dave Ramsey doesn't do subtle. Whether you're a fan or not – there's no denying the man knows how to cut through the noise. Case in point: a call from a 47-year-old who thought he had his financial life somewhat together – until Ramsey dismantled that illusion in under 10 minutes in a call posted to YouTube in January 2025. 

The caller kicked things off with a refreshingly honest admission: "I thought I was pretty fiscally responsible, and then I started to listen to you in 2022 and realized I wasn't as smart as I thought I was. So I'm gonna ask for help." That's like waving a red flag in front of Ramsey, who thrives on turning financial self-deception into teachable moments.

Don't Miss:

• How do billionaires pay less in income tax than you? Tax deferring is their number one strategy.
• If You're Age 35, 50, or 60: Here’s How Much You Should Have Saved Vs. Invested By Now

Turns out, the caller's only debt was a $1,500-a-month payment on a company truck, which his employer partially reimbursed based on mileage. Ramsey wasn't having it. "You get that whether you have a car payment or not, correct?" he asked. The caller confirmed. Cue the classic Ramsey takedown: "Yeah, you just used it to justify debt. The program is independent of debt. It does not require debt." Translation: nice try but no. His advice was clear – ditch the debt, keep the reimbursement and stop pretending one justifies the other.

But the real fireworks happened when the caller mentioned that his tax advisor had recommended switching from a Roth 401(k) to a traditional 401(k) to snag a tax deduction. Ramsey's response? Zero hesitation: "You should fire your tax advisor. I'm serious as a heart attack. They're trading a tax deduction for tax-free growth. This guy can't do math." The caller, already halfway there mentally, admitted, "That's what I thought too, so I kept doing the Roth 401(k) this year and changed tax advisors because I don't know what else he's doing that's dumb."

Trending: The average American couple has saved this much money for retirement — How do you compare?

With that out of the way, they dove into the caller's retirement numbers: $19,000 in a Roth 401(k), $67,000 in a traditional 401(k) and $18,000 in an HSA – all accumulated since April 2022. Ramsey didn't sugarcoat the reality check: "You're a long way from retiring in seven years. I don't think you're going to be mathematically able to live anywhere near like you're living now at 55 years old with no work." But, in a rare softer moment, he added, "That's not a bad thing though. You need to be doing something. I'm 64. I work. It's not the end of the world."

Co-host Ken Coleman chimed in with a perspective that felt more philosophical than financial: "The data is overwhelming for people who want to research it on what happens when you truly stop working. Financial retirement, in my mind, is different from just straight professional ‘I'm not doing anything any longer.' I think that it's not good for the body and it's definitely not good for the soul – not good for the mind. It's a terrible thing to waste."

See Also: Many are using retirement income calculators to check if they’re on pace — here’s a breakdown on what’s behind this formula.

Ramsey agreed, summing it up the only way he knows how – bluntly: "Having enough money to not have to work is different from just not working. That's what you're saying."

By the end of the call, the 47-year-old sounded like a man with a new mission. "I'm gonna get out of the truck debt and I'm gonna jack up on some of these other things – the investment side – and get this thing moving."

So, what's the takeaway here? Besides the fact that Dave Ramsey will never, ever mince words, it's this: financial advice isn't one-size-fits-all. While Ramsey's aggressive debt-free, Roth-over-traditional stance works for many, it doesn't mean it's the perfect approach for everyone. Before making any big money moves – especially with retirement on the horizon – it's smart to consult a qualified financial advisor. Just maybe not the one who thinks trading tax-free growth for a quick deduction is a brilliant idea.

Read Next:

• Can you guess how many retire with a $5,000,000 nest egg? The percentage may shock you.
• Many are surprised by Mark Cuban's advice for lotto winners: Cash or annuity?