Take A $450,000 Pension In A Lump Sum Or $3,000 Monthly Payments? Suze Orman's Advice To Anxious Soon-To-Be Retiree

When preparing for retirement, one of the biggest financial decisions you may face is whether to take a pension as a lump sum or opt for monthly payments. This dilemma recently came up on Suze Orman's “Women & Money” podcast, where a listener named Ellen shared her concerns about an upcoming retirement decision. Ellen was torn between taking a $450,000 lump sum or a $3,000 monthly pension and sought Orman's advice.

Weighing the Options

Ellen wrote, "I had planned to take my pension in a lump sum, approximately $450,000 mainly because I feel it can grow much more than receiving it monthly." However, she also acknowledged that with the pension and Social Security, she would hardly need to touch her investments except for large expenses. This uncertainty led to her feelings of anxiety about making the right choice.

Don't Miss:

• The average American couple has saved this much money for retirement — How do you compare?
• Maker of the $60,000 foldable home has 3 factory buildings, 600+ houses built, and big plans to solve housing — you can become an investor for $0.80 per share today.

Orman approached the question by first identifying an important factor: Ellen did not mention having a spouse. This suggested she was likely considering a “life only” pension, meaning the $3,000 monthly payment would stop upon her death. Without a spouse or dependent beneficiary, the pension would not be transferable, which could impact her long-term financial security.

Orman then broke down the numbers. The $3,000 monthly pension amounts to $36,000 per year, which is about an 8% return on the $450,000 lump sum. This guaranteed income would be stable and unaffected by market fluctuations. However, it would also be fully taxable and would not increase with inflation.

Trending: If You're Age 35, 50, or 60: Here’s How Much You Should Have Saved Vs. Invested By Now

On the other hand, if Ellen took the lump sum and rolled it into an IRA, she could invest it to generate returns. Orman stated that assuming a conservative 5% return, Ellen would receive about $1,800 per month—substantially less than the pension payments. At a 7% return, she could generate around $2,600 per month, which is still lower than the guaranteed $3,000. More importantly, investment returns are not guaranteed, and market downturns could reduce her income over time.

Orman's Advice

Given Ellen's situation, Orman suggested a balanced approach. She recommended considering a combination strategy, such as rolling over a portion of the lump sum into an IRA while using the rest to purchase an income annuity. This would provide a mix of security and growth potential.

Ultimately, Orman leaned toward the pension option for Ellen, especially since she had other investments, including a 403(b) and a Roth IRA. She pointed out that Ellen's anxiety about retirement was a key factor—opting for the pension would provide her with a predictable income, reducing financial stress.

See Also: ‘Scrolling To UBI' — Deloitte's #1 fastest-growing software company allows users to earn money on their phones. You can invest today for just $0.26/share with a $1000 minimum.

Key Takeaways for Retirees

Ellen's dilemma is one that many soon-to-be retirees face. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer, Orman's analysis highlights several important considerations:

• Guaranteed Income vs. Investment Risk: Pensions provide stable, guaranteed income, while lump sums depend on investment performance.
• Longevity and Beneficiaries: If you have a spouse or dependents, a pension's survivor benefits may be an important factor.
• Market Conditions: Investment returns fluctuate, meaning a lump sum may not always generate the expected income if you invest it.
• Personal Comfort Level: If managing investments creates stress, a stable pension may be the better option.

For those facing a similar decision, consulting with a financial professional can provide personalized guidance. Understanding your financial needs, risk tolerance, and long-term goals will help you make the choice that best supports a secure retirement.

Read Next:

• Many are using retirement income calculators to check if they’re on pace — here’s a breakdown on what’s behind this formula.
• Many are surprised by Mark Cuban's advice for lotto winners: Cash or annuity?