If you work for Zynga, now is a good time to quit.
And if you're a Zynga employee who owns company stock, you might want to get a good lawyer.
The
Wall Street Journal reports (via
CNET) that Zynga execs have been telling its employees that it wants them to return their stock options before the company's IPO. The reasons are silly and insidious. When speaking to employees, Zynga argues that it wants the shares back to make the company look more attractive to future talent. Behind the scenes, Zynga is apparently trying to avoid a scenario in which some of its lower-level employees become millionaires because they own a piece of the company.
In other words, GREED, GREED, GREED! Zynga doesn't care about its employees. It doesn't care about future talent. It only cares about its own bottom line. Its chief executive, Mark Pincus, has admitted to doing “
every horrible thing in the book” to get revenues. So why should employees believe him now when he says he's only thinking of the company's future?
They shouldn't. We know better. The truth is that Zynga is and always has been a greedy, questionable firm with a weak business plan and a lackluster distribution model. As someone who has been reporting on the game industry for more than 10 years (and watching it with a close eye for many years before that), I know how this market works. It has always been competitive. But what few seem to realize is that it has never thrived on fads.
Thus, I've been
predicting Zynga's demise for quite some time. Early this fall, the company's profits
declined by roughly 95%. There have been numerous reports that the social game developer is cannibalizing its own market by releasing new games that steal players away from older Zynga titles. I find that revelation particularly amusing. While social games require consistency (players must return often and spend money regularly for Zynga to profit), traditional video games do not.
If every single one of the
6.5 million people who purchased Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 stopped playing right now, it wouldn't matter because Activision has already made its money. With Call of Duty, consumers paid for the game up front. Map expansions and other online goodies are secondary.
Thus, if Modern Warfare 3's buyers decided to start playing another Activision game instead, the company will continue to thrive. No cannibalization takes place. While a decline in Call of Duty play time today could certainly hurt Activision's bottom line with the next Call of Duty release (scheduled for – wait for it – November 2012), the company has a full 12 months to ensure that doesn't happen.
Zynga, on the other hand, does not have 12 months. It does not have a cash cow to carry it through the bad times that are surely ahead (and, looking at the numbers, may have already arrived). It does not have a big, all-powerful franchise with a diehard fan base that will ignore the incoming competition from Electronic Arts
ERTS. Zynga does not have any of that. Simply put, Zynga builds time-killers, not franchises. And it sells those time-killers to a group of people who will pack up and leave the instant another fad catches their attention.
The same cannot be said for Activision (a company that
does build franchises), which is why Battlefield 3
won't beat Call of Duty, even if it is
one of the most impressive games of the year.
Like it or not, Electronic Arts is not (currently) a major threat to Activision's future. But as the
number-two player in social game development, EA has become Zynga's worst nightmare.
Wait, scratch that. Zynga is Zynga's worst nightmare.
ACTION ITEMS:Bullish:
Think I'm overreacting? Then consider this trade:
- Zynga's IPO is scheduled to launch after Thanksgiving (on the NASDAQ under the symbol ZNGA). If you're happy with Zynga now, you could be really, really happy in just a few short weeks.
Don't believe in Zynga's slimy business practices? Have doubts about the company's shoddy development strategy? If so, consider this alternative:
- With or without Zynga on the market, Electronic Arts stands to clean up in social media. But with Zynga out of the picture, there wouldn't be anything stopping EA from becoming the number-one developer in social gaming.
Loading...
Loading...
EAElectronic Arts Inc
$150.48-0.70%
Edge Rankings
Momentum
59.95
Growth
33.28
Quality
35.39
Value
7.88
Price Trend
Short
Medium
Long
© 2025 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.
Posted In:
Benzinga simplifies the market for smarter investing
Trade confidently with insights and alerts from analyst ratings, free reports and breaking news that affects the stocks you care about.
Join Now: Free!
Already a member?Sign in