Wells Fargo Analyst Downgrades ASB, BANC, FIBK, FHN Citing Interest Rate Pressures And Credit Risks

Wells Fargo analyst Timur Braziler has assumed coverage of 15 banks in addition to the seven currently covered. The analyst transferred coverage of midcap banks, downgraded 4 to Equal Weight, and became more selective given the risk to earnings (rates, credit) and delayed consolidation benefits, mitigated by inexpensive valuations.

His new ratings are almost equally split between Overweight and Equal Weight after the downgrade of 4 banks to Equal Weight. The main themes reflect the "3 C's" - Competition for deposits in a higher-for-longer rates environment; Credit given increased normalization in CRE and C&I relative to his prior expectations; and Consolidation that can be a solid long-term tailwind but also seems unlikely to impact the near-term much.

Braziler's top picks include F N B Corp FNB, Western Alliance Bancorp WAL,  East West Bancorp Inc EWBC, Pinnacle Financial Partners Inc PNFP.

FNB benefits by drawing in deposits from lower-cost rural markets and deploying the funds in recently entered, higher-growth geographies. 

WAL remains a beat-and-raise story, as industry-leading deposit growth should again get the shares higher.

EWBC also benefits from idiosyncratic deposit trends and seems among the best positioned from a capital and conservative approach to lending as the group goes through the credit cycle.

PNFP with geography will be the main difference in credit performance. The Southeast is the best-performing geography in the U.S., and PNFP is the best bank in the SE.

Braziler downgraded four banks to Equal Weight from Overweight, namely, Associated Banc-Corp ASB, Banc Of California, Inc BANC, First Interstate BancSystem, Inc FIBK, and First Horizon Corp FHN. The analyst rerated two on macro themes, two for more idiosyncratic reasons, and all due to less sub-sector weighting.

For ASB, a higher-for-longer interest rate environment will pressure NII trends, limiting the near-term possibility of valuation expansion. A combination of a high loan-to-deposit ratio and continued asset growth is going to prove more costly in a higher-rate environment.

For BANC, the analyst still favors the combination with PacWest Bancorp  PACW but sees limited near-term opportunities for shares to move higher until the deal is closed and there is greater clarity in the earnings stream. 

For FIBK, the deposit base has underperformed expectations during the current rising rate environment, and the analyst saw several bumps in credit, including in-office CRE, over the past few quarters, risks that the valuation multiple to this point do not reflect.

While FHN shares trade at a discount to the group in terms of P/TBV and Braziler views FHN as a potential acquisition target in the long-term, idiosyncratic headwinds from several sides and the lack of near-term catalysts are likely to keep investors on the sidelines for the foreseeable future.