Marijuana Or Music? Which Of The Two Was Sold First Over The Internet And When?

The history of online transactions is often clouded in debate, with differing opinions on what constitutes the first true e-commerce sale. Commonly cited as the pioneer is Phil Brandenberger's August 11, 1994, purchase of Sting's "Ten Summoner's Tales" CD. The transaction, facilitated by Dan Kohn's NetMarket startup is widely recognized for pioneering the use of encrypted online payments and ushering in a new era of e-commerce.

Yet, a story dating back to the early 1970s suggests an unconventional beginning for online transactions. Allegedly, students from Stanford University and MIT utilized ARPANET, the precursor to the modern internet, to arrange a marijuana deal. Although this transaction didn't involve a direct exchange of money online and was technically illegal, it is often cited as the "first agreed upon online exchange in history," highlighting its significance despite its disputed status.

NetMarket's 1994 sale stands out as the first secure online transaction, with Kohn emphasizing the security measures involved.

"Even if the N.S.A. was listening in, they couldn't get his credit card number," he told The New York Times​. This transaction demonstrated the practical application of online payment security, an essential component that laid the foundation for today's vast e-commerce industry.

• Cannabis rescheduling seems to be right around the corner. Want to understand what this means for the future of the industry? Hear directly for top executives, investors and policymakers at the 19th Benzinga Cannabis Capital Conference, coming to Chicago this Oct. 8-9. Get your tickets now before prices surge by following this link.

The historical significance of these two transactions speaks to the evolution of digital commerce. While the alleged marijuana sale may have hinted at the potential for online exchanges, it was the secure CD transaction that provided the blueprint for e-commerce as we know it today. It marked a shift in how we view digital transactions, from curiosity to a viable, trustworthy option for commerce.

In tracing the roots of e-commerce, it's crucial to recognize the broader context: early attempts at digital transactions had to overcome significant technological and societal challenges. The Sting CD sale symbolizes the realization of a vision for online shopping that is now ubiquitous, while the ARPANET exchange represents the nascent ideas that eventually shaped our digital economy.

These divergent narratives encapsulate the complexities of e-commerce's origins, revealing how innovation often springs from unlikely sources, evolves unpredictably, and reshapes our world in ways we couldn't have imagined.

Cover image by Javier Hasse.

This content was partially produced with the help of AI tools and was reviewed and published by Benzinga editors.