Bitcoin Advocates Fire Back At European Central Bank, Say 'Vested Interest' Motivated Criticism

A recent European Central Bank (ECB) working paper criticizing Bitcoin BTC/USD has sparked strong reactions from cryptocurrency academics, accusing the paper of bias and flawed analysis.

What Happened: The paper, released on Oct. 12 by ECB authors Ulrich Bindseil and Jürgen Schaaf, painted a negative picture of Bitcoin's future viability, focusing on its volatility, wealth concentration, and lack of productive contributions.

In response, a group of crypto academics published a rebuttal on Oct. 22, challenging the ECB's findings and defending Bitcoin's value and utility.

Murray Rudd, from the Bitcoin advocacy group Satoshi Action Fund, led the critique, accusing the ECB paper of misinterpreting Bitcoin’s primary purpose and technological foundations.

"By focusing on the early limitations, Bindseil and Schaff fail to acknowledge the significant progress made in improving its scalability and efficiency," Rudd said.

He added that the authors’ claims of Bitcoin evolving from a payment method to an investment asset demonstrated a misunderstanding of its decentralized nature and proof-of-work system.

The rebuttal argued that the ECB's analysis of Bitcoin's wealth concentration overlooked the fact that many large wallets are managed by exchanges holding funds for millions of users.

Also Read: Nigeria Drops Money Laundering Charges Against Binance Executive Amid Diplomatic Pressure

It also noted that Bitcoin's volatility is a characteristic of its early-stage adoption, a common trend in new technologies, rather than a critical flaw.

Additionally, the critique stated that the paper ignored Bitcoin’s growing role as a store of value and its potential to hedge against inflation, citing the decreasing purchasing power of traditional currencies like the U.S. dollar.

Rudd further questioned the impartiality of the ECB paper's authors, noting their involvement in the development of the digital euro, a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC).

"Given the ECB's strategic focus on developing a CBDC, it is reasonable to infer that the authors, at best, have a vested interest in portraying Bitcoin as an inferior, speculative asset," he said.

The rebuttal accused the ECB of downplaying Bitcoin's benefits, such as its role in financial inclusion, cross-border payments, and its potential for energy efficiency improvements.

What’s Next: This will be a key topic of discussion at Benzinga's Future of Digital Assets event on Nov. 19, where industry leaders will delve into the evolving relationship between cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin and emerging CBDCs, and how these developments could shape global finance moving forward.

Read Next:

• Crypto On The Ballot? Nope, Even Young Male Voters Prioritize Inflation, Jobs And The Economy

Image: Shutterstock